How to Tell If Your Shoes Are Real Leather

How to Tell If Your Shoes Are Real Leather

In a world full of fast fashion and synthetic materials, it can be hard to tell whether your shoes are made of genuine leather or not. Many brands label their products as "leather" without specifying the quality—or worse, they use misleading terms like “PU leather” or “vegan leather” that are actually synthetic.

If you're investing in quality footwear, especially from a premium brand like Oxford Elite, knowing how to identify real leather is key. In this guide, we’ll show you the signs, tests, and tips that help you spot the real deal.

Why It Matters: Real Leather vs. Fake Leather

Real leather ages beautifully, breathes well, and offers unmatched durability and comfort. In contrast, faux leather often cracks, peels, and lacks the rich look and feel of the genuine product.

At Oxford Elite, we use only premium full-grain leather—sourced ethically and crafted by hand. Understanding what sets real leather apart helps you appreciate the quality you're wearing.

7 Ways to Tell If Your Shoes Are Real Leather

1. Check the Label (But Don’t Rely on It)

Start with the label or product description. Phrases like:

  • "Genuine Leather"
  • "Full-Grain Leather"
  • "Top-Grain Leather"

...indicate authentic material. However, avoid shoes labeled with:

  • “PU Leather”
  • “Faux Leather”
  • “Synthetic Upper”

These are not real leather.

💡 At Oxford Elite, we clearly label all of our products with the exact leather type used, with full transparency.

2. Smell the Leather

Real leather has a distinct, rich, earthy smell that’s hard to replicate. Faux leather often smells like plastic or chemicals due to synthetic coatings.

✅ Real leather: Natural, rich, slightly sweet

❌ Fake leather: Sharp, chemical, or plasticky scent

3. Look at the Grain

Genuine leather has natural imperfections—tiny wrinkles, pores, or texture inconsistencies. These "flaws" are actually proof that it's real.

  • Full-grain leather keeps the outer layer intact, showing unique patterns.
  • Fake leather often looks too smooth, with a machine-made, uniform texture.

4. Touch & Feel the Surface

Run your hand over the shoe:

  • Real leather feels warm, soft, and slightly grainy.
  • Synthetic leather feels cold, plasticky, or rubbery.

Try pressing gently on the surface:

  • Real leather will wrinkle slightly, like skin.
  • Faux leather will stay stiff or bounce back without creasing.

5. The Water Drop Test (Optional for Older Shoes)

Drop a tiny bit of water onto the leather:

  • Real leather absorbs moisture slowly—creating a dark spot that fades over time.
  • Fake leather repels water and the droplet will just sit on top.

⚠️ Only do this test on older or non-treated leather shoes—not on new or polished pairs, as it might affect the finish.

6. Check the Edges

Look at the edges of the shoe leather:

  • Real leather has a rough, fibrous edge.
  • Faux leather looks perfect, with smooth or plasticky edges from factory cuts.

🧵 At Oxford Elite, you’ll notice the natural grain and hand-cut edges in every pair—proof of authenticity.

7. Flex & Bend Test

Gently bend the shoe:

  • Real leather will develop small creases or wrinkles in the surface.
  • Fake leather will usually remain rigid or show unnatural crinkling.

This is a subtle but powerful way to spot quality, especially in areas like the toe box or heel counter.

Bonus Tip: Price Often Reflects Quality

While not always 100% reliable, price can be a helpful indicator. Real leather is more expensive due to sourcing, tanning, and craftsmanship. If a shoe claims to be leather but is extremely cheap, it's likely fake or bonded leather (a mix of scraps and glue).

Oxford Elite's Leather Promise

We don't cut corners. Every Oxford Elite shoe is made using:

  • Full-grain or top-grain leather
  • Ethical sourcing
  • Hand-finishing techniques
  • Traditional craftsmanship

Our goal is simple: To offer footwear that looks better, fits better, and lasts longer.

Final Thoughts: Know What You're Wearing

In a market full of imitation, knowledge is power. Knowing how to tell if your shoes are made of real leather empowers you to make better purchases, care for your shoes properly, and invest in products that truly last.

If you’re ready to step into authentic craftsmanship, comfort, and style—Oxford Elite has the perfect pair waiting for you.

Ready to Feel the Difference of Real Leather?

👉 Explore Oxford Elite’s handcrafted leather shoes today—where tradition meets modern style.
Shop the Collection

Back to blog